The Erosion of Independence: Why the No Surprises Act is a Lifeline for Private Practice

By Ritha Belizaire, MD
November 21, 2026

In October 2023, a 19-year-old patient arrived at the emergency department, his body ravaged by a perforated appendix. By the time I navigated the complex, inflammation-distorted anatomy in the operating room, the procedure had stretched from a standard 15-minute operation to an hour-and-a-half intensive surgery. My commitment didn’t end at the exit of the OR; I rounded on him daily for a week to ensure he was stable for discharge and continued to provide critical post-operative follow-up for two months.

When the reimbursement check from the insurance company finally arrived, the amount was $6.73.

This was not a clerical error or a processing glitch. It was the "contracted rate" determined by the insurer for a complex, life-saving intervention. Because the procedure was subject to a 90-day global billing period—a standard insurance policy that bundles all follow-up care into the initial surgical fee—that $6.73 was the insurer’s final word on the value of a teenager’s life and my professional expertise.

For solo, independent physicians, stories like this are not outliers; they are the status quo. The federal No Surprises Act (NSA), while originally designed to protect patients from predatory billing, has inadvertently become a vital, albeit imperfect, shield for the remaining independent medical practitioners in America.

The Reality of Independent Practice in a Corporate Era

I opened Houston Community Surgical in 2023 after years in academic medicine. I left that world because I wanted to prioritize patient needs over the rigid, profit-driven spreadsheets of hospital administrators. However, I soon discovered that the struggle for professional autonomy had merely shifted from hospital bureaucracy to the boardrooms of massive insurance carriers.

When I first opened my doors, the economic reality was stark. To sustain my practice, I maintained a part-time role at a county hospital and took on emergency general surgery calls at another facility for a meager $40 an hour. For six months, I worked four concurrent jobs. I drained my 401(k) and, as a single mother providing for two daughters, I spent my nights performing the grim arithmetic of a small business owner: calculating how to cover staff salaries, office rent, malpractice premiums, and my mortgage. For two years, I drew no salary, often questioning whether the pursuit of independent medicine was a dream I could afford to maintain.

My experience is mirrored by a national trend. According to the Physicians Advocacy Institute, the percentage of physicians in independent practice plummeted from 37.8% in 2019 to just 22.4% by 2024. Today, over 75% of doctors are employed by hospitals or private equity-backed corporate entities. Every physician who abandons independent practice leaves behind a piece of the patient-doctor relationship, trading clinical judgment for corporate metrics.

The Arbitration Process: A Check on Insurer Power

The NSA’s Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR) process provides a neutral, third-party mechanism to challenge inadequate insurer payments. When a physician and an insurer cannot agree on a fair rate for care already provided, both parties submit a final offer to an arbitrator, who must select one of the two figures.

Critics have argued that because physicians win these disputes more than 80% of the time, the system is biased in favor of doctors. This is a profound misreading of the data. That win rate is not evidence of a broken system; it is an indictment of the predatory initial offers made by insurance companies.

An analysis of nearly 160,000 arbitration cases revealed that insurers offered $0 to the physician in over 20,000 instances. In the fourth quarter of 2024, approximately one-quarter of all disputes were resolved by default, often because the insurance company failed to provide adequate documentation or simply neglected to make a formal offer. When an insurer’s opening position is “zero,” an arbitrator does not need to look hard to find a more equitable outcome.

Chronology of a Crisis: From Surgery to Arbitration

The trajectory of my practice highlights how these systemic issues play out in real time:

  • October 2023: I perform a life-saving appendectomy on a 19-year-old patient. The insurer provides a $6.73 payment for the procedure and months of follow-up care.
  • Early 2024: A patient presents with severe anemia and a bowel obstruction caused by a large colon tumor. I perform a successful robotic colectomy. The insurer denies the claim entirely, citing that the procedure was "not medically necessary."
  • Mid-2024: After exhausting standard appeals, I utilize the NSA arbitration process for the first time. The process is lengthy—often taking eight months to resolve—but it represents the only tool available to challenge the insurer’s denial.
  • Late 2024 – Present: As I continue to navigate the IDR process, I observe a pattern of insurers under-calculating or refusing to pay for legitimate emergency services, betting that the administrative burden of arbitration will discourage physicians from fighting back.

Implications for the Future of Healthcare

The financial pressure on independent surgeons is not just about the loss of personal income; it is about the viability of small-scale, patient-centered care. When an insurer refuses to pay for a robotic colectomy by labeling it "medically unnecessary," they are not just attacking my bottom line—they are undermining the clinical decision-making that saves lives.

The argument that physicians are "gaming" the No Surprises Act ignores the power dynamic at play. We are not asking for sympathy; we are asking for a level playing field. If the arbitration tool is weakened or removed under the guise of cost-containment, the result will be the total consolidation of the American healthcare market.

We are currently witnessing the end-stage of corporatization. When hospitals and private equity firms absorb the last of the independent practices, they will not necessarily drive down costs—they will simply centralize them. Patients will lose the ability to see a doctor who knows their history and has the time to provide thoughtful care, and physicians will lose the ability to act as the final authority on their patients’ health.

A Call for Transparency

The next time a policy analyst or insurance executive suggests that the NSA is being exploited by greedy physicians, they should be forced to answer a simple question: Why was an insurer’s opening offer for a week of intensive post-operative care following a ruptured appendix only $6.73?

The No Surprises Act was written to protect patients from being blindsided by medical bills. However, it serves a secondary, equally vital purpose: it protects the doctors who are still willing to stand up for their patients against the profit-first models of major insurers.

If we allow the current, flawed system of insurance payments to continue without a check like the IDR process, we will not only lose the independent practitioner; we will lose the soul of the medical profession. For those of us still fighting to keep our doors open, arbitration is not just a regulatory hurdle—it is the thin line between a sustainable practice and the total erasure of independent medicine in America.

We must protect this process. Our patients, and the future of our healthcare system, depend on it.

More From Author

The "China-In-License" Revolution: How Biotech Venture Capital Transformed the Drug Development Playbook